Categories: Getting Started,Retirement
Bookmarks: del.icio.us, reddit
Over the last few months, I’ve read several articles that center around the idea that people should be saving every possible dime that they can for retirement. For example, Daily Finance recently had an article entitled Forget the 4% Rule: Retirement’s Common Wisdom Is Obsolete:
The theory was simple: If you spent a maximum of 4% per year of your retirement funds, the decline in principle will be slow enough that your money would last as long as you did. Though the percentage seems modest and the reasoning sound, this 4% rule ignores two factors that have become increasingly, glaringly relevant: first, market volatility, which has battered retirement savings over the last decade, and second, inflation, the silent force that erodes purchasing power year after year.
What does that mean?
The other issue with basing your retirement plan on simple rules is that it can lead to complacency. But the idea that you can “set it and forget it” and everything will be fine is a trap.
“There are so many ‘experts’ telling people different things, that they’re not going to have to worry,” D’Arruda said. “A rule means something in writing, something enforceable. But in retirement planning, there’s a fluctuating source. You can’t take a guarantee.”
Let’s look at an example case from a reader that I’ll call Marvin.
Marvin has $800,000 put away for retirement, mostly in really conservative stuff like bonds and cash. Overall, he’s earning about 2% a year on his money. He was bitten by the stock market collapse in 2008 and doesn’t want his money in stocks. Marvin wants to retire in ten years, so he wanted to know how much money he should be putting away.
I asked him a few questions. How much does he anticipate spending (in current dollars) per year in retirement? He told me about $50,000. What will his Social Security benefits look like? He estimated around $1,500 a month (adding up to about $18,000 a year).
I told him that if he wants to retire in ten years, he should be putting away every single dime he can starting right now and that he should anticipate trying to earn at least some income during his retirement.
I don’t think Marvin liked that answer.
Why did I tell him that, though? The big reason is that his plans for retirement are riddled with uncertainty.
First of all, there’s inflation. Let’s say inflation grows at 3% a year for the next thirty years. If he’s estimating spending $50,000 in today’s money, during his first year in retirement, he’s going to be spending just shy of $70,000. During his eleventh year? $93,000. That’s more than 10% of his total retirement balance. His Social Security might go up a little, but it’s not going to go up that much.
There’s also the issue of fluctuation in investment returns. Right now, Marvin is very conservative and only earning a 2% return on his money. That’s not enough of a return to build substantial wealth. With that level of return, unless he contributes more, he’s not going to even crack $1 million for his retirement plans.
If he moves into stocks, he will likely get a higher long-term average annual return, but it will be highly volatile. He might average out to 5%, but one year might see a 20% loss while two other years might see 15% gains. Volatility at the wrong moment in retirement can eliminate years of living expenses and you won’t have time to see the market rebound save you.
There’s also the issue of uncertain lifespans. If Marvin retires at 65 and lives until 75, he’ll be fine. If Marvin retires at 65 and lives until 95, he’s going to be in big trouble. None of us know for certain how long we’ll live.
The article seems to imply that individuals shouldn’t be involved in planning for this and that financial advisors know better. I don’t really agree with that. All of these factors rely on knowing unknowable facts about the future. No financial advisor in the world can tell you how long you’ll live, how volatile the stock market or other investments will be in the next ten years, or what inflation will do in the future.
However, there’s one thing that almost no one can argue with. The more money you save for retirement, the more money you’ll have when it comes time to retire. The more you put in now, the more you get out later.
The solution is simple. You can either save as much as possible for retirement now so you don’t really have to worry about this too much. On the other hand, you can save less and accept that your final years will likely involve leaner living.
I am almost always of the belief that if I can make a minor sacrifice now, that’s far better than having to make a major sacrifice later. If I can squeeze out another $1,000 a year right now, that might add up to another $1,500 a year in retirement.
It might make the difference between never going out to eat with my wife or having a nice dinner out with her once a month.
What do I have to sacrifice today to get there? If it’s something small that I can give up and apply that savings to additional retirement savings, then it’s well worth it.
That’s how I look at retirement savings. I’m making little sacrifices now so that I can enjoy life more later on. If I can resist that new gadget that I don’t really need and probably won’t use very much today, I can have some breathing room and a little less stress and a little more fun later on.
It is never a bad move to save more for retirement.
Related PostsWhat Matters Most to You? Planning for a Very Long Life
Predicting the Future: Will People In Their Twenties Today Collect Social Security In Retirement? And How Should That Answer Change Our Plans?
Making Retirement Savings Tangible
Tying Investment Risk To Your Goals
Borrowing Against A Retirement Plan To Make A 20% Down Payment
-->
Did you like this article? You can get the complete text of all the latest articles at The Simple Dollar in your email inbox each morning by entering your email address below. Your address will only be used for mailing you the articles, and each one will include a link so you can unsubscribe at any time.
Comments #1 Johanna @ 8:18 am April 22nd, 2012The 4% rule DOES account for volatility and inflation.
#2 Johanna @ 8:18 am April 22nd, 2012And Trent never answered Marvin’s question…
#3 Johanna @ 8:19 am April 22nd, 2012Unless his answer is “No amount of savings is EVER enough”
#4 Johanna @ 8:19 am April 22nd, 2012Which is just silly.
#5 kc @ 8:27 am April 22nd, 2012Another insipid post. Trent, stick to coupons.
#6 Johanna @ 8:39 am April 22nd, 2012“Save every dime” is an OK strategy for a young person
#7 Johanna @ 8:40 am April 22nd, 2012But eventually, you have to ask “Do I have enough to retire now, or not?”
#8 Johanna @ 8:41 am April 22nd, 2012And Trent offers no insight into that.
#9 Interested Readers @ 9:44 am April 22nd, 2012Don’t believe Trent reads this. Think he has these up to “auto post”.
#10 Interested Readers @ 9:46 am April 22nd, 2012Wonder how long it would take Trent to notice if everyone stopped making comments.
#11 julie @ 10:37 am April 22nd, 2012Time to retire from TSD?
Leave a reply
name (required)
email ( will not be shown ) (required)
website
Constructive comments of all kinds are welcome. Negativity is not.
If you're going to criticize the statements of others, supply supporting information that backs up your statement or your comment will be deleted.
Comments that don't contribute to the growth and thoughtfulness of other readers will be deleted.
Next Post: Read Your Favorite Newspaper Online (112/365)
Get The Book!
My new book, The Simple Dollar: How One Man Wiped Out His Debts and Achieved the Life of His Dreams, is available in bookstores now! Check out some of the life-changing experiences the book has given readers! Buy it at Amazon.com or buy it from Barnes & Noble or pick it up at your local bookstore today!Amazon.com Barnes & Noble
Best Buy
Gap
Macy's.com
Newegg.com
Overstock.com
PetSmart
Restaurant.com
Sears Outlet
Staples
Target.com
Walmart.com
View Complete Coupon Directory
Subscribe! Receive The Simple Dollar by email every day, or subscribe via RSS!
Also, if you're a fan, consider becoming a friend of The Simple Dollar!
Rate CenterToday's Average Rates Across the Country*RefinanceSavings / MMACDsAuto InsuranceJavaScript must be enabled to use this widget.ProductNatl AvgFeatured30 Yr Fixed5.05%4.67%15 Yr Fixed4.43%3.81%5/1 ARM3.81%3.13%COMPARE RATESRefinance Rates provided by
Min BalanceNatl AvgFeatured< $10k0.25%1.15%$10k - $24.9k0.30%1.14%$25k - $49.9k0.40%1.14%COMPARE RATESSavings Accounts and Money Market Rates provided by 
TermNatl AvgFeatured6 Month CD0.38%0.92%1 Year CD0.59%1.22%5 Year CD1.75%2.27%Compare Terms: - - Select One - - 6 Month CD1 Year CD2 Year CD5 Year CDCD Rates provided by Vehicle TypeYearly PremiumCars$1,544.58
Trucks$1,419.25SUVs$1,346.76See Your Rate: - - Select One - - AlabamaAlaskaArizonaArkansasCaliforniaColoradoConnecticutDelawareDistrict of ColumbiaFloridaGeorgiaHawaiiIdahoIllinoisIndianaIowaKansasKentuckyLouisianaMaineMarylandMassachusettsMichiganMinnesotaMississippiMissouriMontanaNebraskaNevadaNew HampshireNew JerseyNew MexicoNew YorkNorth CarolinaNorth DakotaOhioOklahomaOregonPennsylvaniaRhode IslandSouth CarolinaSouth DakotaTennesseeTexasUtahVermontVirginiaWashingtonWest VirginiaWisconsinWyomingCar Insurance Rates provided by 
Twitter! You should follow me on Twitter here! I update with interesting links and thoughts a couple times a day - and no boring conversation you don't care about! If you want to receive links to updates to The Simple Dollar on Twitter, you can follow 'thesimpledollar' to get those updates. Free eBook! Download my free 49 page personal finance book, Everything You Ever Really Needed to Know About Personal Finance On Just One Page! 365 Ways to Live Cheap Check out my book, 365 Ways to Live Cheap, available in bookstores everywhere! You can also pick it up from Amazon.com for just $7.95 and from Barnes and Noble for just $7.95! It's filled with 365 great tactics you can apply to your personal finances, from frugal tips to great ideas for managing your money. Trent's 14 Money Rules 1. Spend Less Than You Earn.
2. Don't Over-Think Your Investments.
3. Stop Wasting Time.
4. Eliminate (and Avoid) High-Interest Debt.
5. Talk About Money (And Be Honest).
6. Stop Trying to Impress Other People.
7. Watch Your Progress (But Make It Fun).
8. Take Care of Your Things.
9. Do It Yourself.
10. Plan Ahead Every Time You Spend.
11. Find and Work Toward Your True Passions.
12. Build Real Friendships and Relationships.
13. Improve Yourself Every Chance You Get.
14. Give Without Strings or Regrets.
Archives
Single Page | Chronology | Book Review Index
2012: Jan Feb Mar Apr
2011: Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
2010: Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
2009: Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
2008: Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
2007: Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
2006: Oct Nov Dec
31 Days to Fix Your Finances A series of exercises helping you center your financial life around your own core values.
The One Hour Project Thirty one-hour projects you can do to improve your financial situation.
Twenty Great Ideas Twenty personal finance and development books, boiled down to three to five pages each.
Building a Better Blog A collection of all of my blogging techniques - great reading if you're thinking of starting a blog of your own. Recent Articles » Read Your Favorite Newspaper Online (112/365)» » Go Through the “Clutter Attractors” Regularly (111/365)» Ten Pieces of Inspiration #70» Start a “Mail Basket” and Process It Weekly (110/365)» Dependency» Every Time You Buy an Item, Get Rid of One (109/365)» Reader Mailbag: Listening» Borrow Stuff You’ll Only Use Once or Twice (108/365)» The Simple Dollar Weekly Roundup: Strange and Beautiful Day Edition» Trim Your Magazine Subscriptions (107/365)» The AT&T/Verizon Duopoly (Infographic) Categories Getting Started (1119)Frugality (673)
Books (623)
Morning Roundup (495)
Reader Mailbag (332)
Investing (236)
Food (228)
Careers (184)
Psychology (159)
Personal Productivity / Personal Development (152)
Parenting (151)
Debt (149)
Book Club (141)
Meta (115)
365 Ways to Live Cheap (110)
Shopping (97)
Housing (90)
Planning (89)
Goals (87)
Time Machine (81)
Retirement (74)
Family (70)
Pieces of Inspiration (68)
Automobile (65)
Saving Money (63)
The Simple Dollar ArtistsThese two people contributed a significant amount of incidental art to The Simple Dollar during its' earliest days at no cost and with no questions asked. I am forever grateful for their support.
Daizy H. (art)
David Herring (art)
Blogs I Read Bargaineering
ChristianPF
Clever Dude
Consumerism Commentary
Deal Seeking Mom
Dumb Little Man
Five Cent Nickel
Freelance Switch
Free Money Finance
Frugal Dad
Get Rich Slowly
I Will Teach You To Be Rich
Len Penzo
Lifehacker
Man Vs. Debt
Money Saving Mom
PF Advice
Pick the Brain
Red Tape Chronicles
Smart Spending
The Digerati Life
The Happiness Project
Unclutterer
Wise Bread
Zen Habits
The information on this site is in the public domain. Read this for more information. Read the privacy policy. Read the image use policy.This site is for entertainment purposes only. Trent is not a financial advisor and no information found on this site should be construed as financial advice.
Please note that thesimpledollar.com has financial relationships with some of the merchants mentioned here. Thesimpledollar.com may be compensated if consumers choose to utilize the links located throughout the content on this site and generate sales for the said merchant.
Top Merchant CouponsAmazon.com
Barnes & Noble
Best Buy
Gap
Macy's.com
Newegg.com
Overstock.com
Restaurant.com
Sears Outlet
Sports Authority
Staples
Target.com
Walmart.com
Accessories Direct
Accuscore
Hotels.com
Kensington
Kmart
Kodak
Match.com
Mattel
Mint.com
Mothernature.com
Motosport
Muscle & Strength
Panasonic
Gamestop
Gardener's Supply
Geico
Gap
Healthcompare Insurance
Hotels.com
Hotwire
PetSmart
HSN.com
Sharper Image
T-Mobile
Walgreens
Warner Bros. Online Shop
View Complete Coupon Directory A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | K | L | M | N | O | P | Q | R | S | T | U | V | W | X | Y | Z
Brak komentarzy:
Prześlij komentarz